Why Essential Knowledge is Forgotten: The Battle to Retain Medical Genetics

In a world where genomic medicine is advancing at breakneck speed, many medical graduates have gaps in the fundamentals they will need to diagnose and treat their patients.

Medical Education Knowledge Retention Genetics

Medical Genetics has ceased to be a marginal specialty to become the transversal axis of modern medicine. From personalized medicine to gene therapies, genetic knowledge increasingly underpins clinical decisions.

However, there is a worrying paradox: while genetics becomes more relevant, medical students struggle to retain its fundamental content. What prevents future doctors from assimilating the knowledge that will determine their professional practice?

A revealing study conducted at the University of Medical Sciences of Las Tunas, Cuba, identified that 94.1% of the students evaluated showed poor mastery of the Medical Genetics content necessary for their clinical practice 3 .

The Diagnosis: When Knowledge Fails to Anchor

The Cuban research, which examined 51 fifth and sixth year medical students, discovered alarming patterns in the loss of essential knowledge. The future doctors had already taken and passed the Medical Genetics course in their second year, but upon reaching the clinical cycles, they showed significant gaps 3 .

The applied pedagogical test revealed that 84.2% of students had scarce mastery of the molecular and cellular bases of inheritance, fundamental knowledge for understanding the mechanisms of genetic diseases 3 .

Retention of Basic Medical Genetics Concepts

Knowledge Retention Crisis

The data, obtained from research published in 2020, reflects that concepts such as translation (essential for understanding protein synthesis) were only remembered by less than 20% of the surveyed students 3 .

DNA Replication 27.5%
Transcription 21.6%
Translation 19.6%
Mitosis 52.9%
Meiosis 35.3%

Factors Behind Forgetting: Why Knowledge Isn't Retained

The study identified several critical factors that explain these deficiencies in knowledge retention:

Inadequate Teaching Methods

Students reported that traditional methods focused on memorization rather than applied reasoning predominated. The scarce use of innovative teaching media and the lack of connection with real clinical situations hindered learning significance 3 .

Intrinsic Complexity & Insufficient Bibliography

The very nature of genetics, with abstract and rapidly evolving concepts, represents a pedagogical challenge. Students pointed out deficiencies in the bibliographic materials available, which were not always updated with the latest advances 3 .

Disconnection with Professional Practice

One of the most significant findings was the disconnection between the contents taught and their application in future professional performance. Students did not visualize the practical utility of this knowledge for clinical reasoning, which undermined their motivation to learn it 3 .

Solutions: Reinventing Medical Genetics Education

Active & Contextualized Strategies

The research recommends implementing teaching-learning strategies where active methods that place the student at the center of the process predominate. The use of problem situations contextualized in real clinical scenarios allows linking genetic knowledge with its practical application 3 .

Technology & Simulations

The incorporation of augmented and virtual reality offers promising opportunities to create realistic simulations of molecular genetic processes. Studies indicate that students who use VR simulations show 30% better performance in practical skills compared to those who receive traditional training 2 .

VR Learning Advantage
30%

Better performance in practical skills

Transversal Integration

Given that the curriculum demands diagnosing health problems based on knowledge of basic biomedical sciences, transversal integration of genetics content throughout the entire degree is recommended, reinforcing its application in different clinical contexts 3 .

Year 1-2: Foundational Concepts

Basic genetics principles integrated with anatomy and physiology

Year 3-4: Clinical Applications

Genetic diagnosis and counseling in various medical specialties

Year 5-6: Advanced Integration

Personalized medicine, pharmacogenetics, and genomic technologies

The Urgency to Train Specialists: A New Horizon in 2025

The need to improve training in Medical Genetics has led the Ministry of Health of Spain to approve in June 2025 the creation of the specialties of Medical Genetics and Laboratory Genetics .

These new specialties, with a duration of four years, represent a historical milestone in the consolidation of personalized medicine in Spain. Medical Genetics will be reserved for Medicine graduates, while Laboratory Genetics will be open to graduates in Medicine, Pharmacy, Biology, Chemistry and Veterinary .

Medical Genetics
  • Access: Medicine Graduates
  • Duration: 4 years
  • Scope of Practice: Diagnosis, prevention and personalized treatment of diseases
Laboratory Genetics
  • Access: Graduates in Medicine, Pharmacy, Biology, Chemistry and Veterinary
  • Duration: 4 years
  • Scope of Practice: Molecular analysis, genetic diagnosis and translational research
This regulatory development responds to the need for professionals with specific training in a field that has transformed the care model, placing genetics at the center of prevention, early diagnosis and individualized treatment .

The Modern Medical Geneticist's Toolkit

Technological advancement has provided specialists with increasingly sophisticated tools for the diagnosis and treatment of genetic diseases:

Tool or Technology Function and Application
Whole Genome Sequencing Identification of genetic variants associated with diseases
CRISPR-Cas9 Precise gene editing for mutation correction
Artificial Intelligence Analysis of genomic data and patterns associated with diseases
Messenger RNA Development of vaccines and therapies for genetic diseases
Nanoparticles Vehicles for targeted gene therapy
Recent Breakthroughs

These tools are revolutionizing the approach to genetic diseases. For example, in 2024 positive results have been obtained in gene therapies for conditions such as Fanconi anemia and some types of hereditary deafness, while artificial intelligence has demonstrated 94% accuracy in detecting breast cancer in mammograms 5 2 .

AI Diagnostic Accuracy
94%

Accuracy in breast cancer detection

Looking to the Future: Medical Genetics in the Era of Personalized Medicine

The II Ibero-American Congress of Medical Genetics and Genomic Medicine, which will take place in Murcia in October 2025, will address the major current and future challenges in this discipline, including global genomics projects, advances in pharmacogenetics and personalized medicine, as well as the ethical implications of these advances 4 .

The growing importance of genetics in medical practice makes it urgent to address the problems of content retention during training. Advances in this field will not be of much use if the doctors of the future do not have the necessary bases to understand and apply them.

As the Cuban researchers point out, the solution involves transforming teaching strategies, favoring active methods and novel and motivating teaching media that connect genetic knowledge with the real needs of clinical practice 3 .

The challenge is complex, but the advancement of medicine depends on us addressing it with determination and creativity.

References